Picking a Babysitter

So a couple with two young children is about to go out for the evening, and they call a babysitter service. Since they called with short notice, they only have two potential sitters to choose from. The service sends over a short description of each that outlines their plusses and minuses.

“So who have we got?” Dad asks.

“Hmmm,” Mom says. “The first one is a guy named Jeffrey Dahmer.”

“Okay, is he any good?” Dad asks.

“Well, there are problems,” Mom says. “Says here that he’s killed seventeen people.”


“Yeah,” Mom says, nodding. “Plus he dismembered them and ate them. Pretty gross, actually.”

“Don’t tell me you’re even considering him.”

“Well,” Mom says, “the other choice is Jerry Sandusky.”


“He’s the former assistant Penn State football coach who was convicted of 52 counts of child molestation.”

“A football coach!” Dad says. “Cool! Wasn’t he a good football coach?”

“Well, yes,” Mom says, “but -”

“That shows he’s competent,” Dad says. “Certainly more competent than that Dahmer guy. What, has he ever even held a job? Sandusky was very well-respected. He won awards and everything.”

“He’s a serial pedophile.”

“Well, yeah, but if you set that aside for a moment…”

Mom gasps. “Set that aside?!”

“Well,” Dad says, “wouldn’t you agree that he’d be better than Jeffrey Dahmer?”

“Sandusky molests children! We can’t leave our kids alone with him!”

“Well, molesting children is bad, but isn’t killing them and eating them worse?”

Mom can’t believe what she’s hearing. “Neither one of them is acceptable,” she insists.

“But for the sake of argument,” Dad says, “wouldn’t you agree that you’d rather have our children molested than murdered?”

“What? How am I supposed to answer that?”

“I’m not saying having our kids molested is good,” Dad says. “I’m just saying it’s better than the alternative. I, for one, would rather keep my kids alive, thank you very much.”

“I, for one, would rather make sure my kids are neither murdered nor molested. I’m calling a different sitter.”

“What?” Dad says, shocked. “You can’t call a different sitter. This is the service we always use!”

“But neither of these choices is acceptable!”

“Well, one is clearly more acceptable than the other.”

“No. Both are unacceptable.”

“So you think pedophilia is as bad as cannibalism?” Dad asks, his voice rising. “Is that it? Are you really saying that?”

“I’m saying that the comparison itself is ludicrous,” Mom says. “Both pedophilia and cannibalism are so awful that neither can ever be considered as viable options.”

“These are the choices,” Dad said. “And I, for one, want my kids alive when we come home.”

“I do, too, but..”

“And look here!” Dad says as he checks his email inbox. “The service just sent us a new Mp3. It’s a secret recording of Dahmer where he talks about how much he likes to eat people. He even uses a bad word!”

“So?” Mom asks.

So? Doesn’t this change your mind? Doesn’t this mean we have to pick Sandusky?”

“Is there any information in there that you didn’t already have?” Mom asks.


“You already know he’s a cannibal. How does hearing him talk about cannibalism make him even worse?”

“I knew it,” Dad says. “You’re a closet cannibal lover.”

Suddenly, the ground opens up and swallows everyone whole.


The end.

Explaining and Losing

One thought on “Picking a Babysitter”

  1. I know this has nothing to do with the subject, but this is kind of the last of what’s left of the Moist Board, so thought I would comment here.

    I’m starting to wish I could go back and read a lot of my old comments from the TNS/TOS arguments, because while I remember people being hostile to TNS fans, I certainly don’t discount the possibility that I was acting like an utter brat. Now especially, because the shoe is officially on the other foot for the first time.

    Specifically, the new Power Rangers movie is the first major adaptation of a property I grew up on. And, I’ve already gotten in one argument with a person who thinks I need to “stop wanting the original.” Said argument left me going “…is that what I was like?”

    Now, I should clarify that there’s one key difference here that I am sure of: I actually did like the trailer for the new Power Rangers. However, I made it clear in a discussion that I (…wow, the similarities…) kind of wish they’d gone with a lighter tone like the original show (I think a tone similar to Guardians of the Galaxy would have worked).

    The person I got into an argument with ignored any comment I made in which I indicated that I didn’t hate the trailer, and just kept piling on me like I was going to change my mind if he insisted enough. He also kept demanding that I watch the interviews with the film makers, because if I wanted something closer to the original it would obviously because I didn’t realize they never intended to make something similar to the original.

    Seriously, MASSIVE “is this what I was like?” moment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *